
A Sister once told me she uses AI as part of her spiritual life, including spiritual direction. I’ve thought about that conversation since. If someone told me they were turning to a chatbot to talk about something they were struggling with, I’d want to know what they found helpful. I’d also want them to feel comfortable telling me about it again.
It’s easy to see why someone might turn to AI. When the house is quiet and everyone else is asleep, a chatbot will answer. It won’t hurry you along if you need a few tries to say what you mean. The comfort a person takes from that conversation is real. What a chatbot can offer ends with the conversation. A friend who knows you can hear something in your voice and decide to call again tomorrow.
There’s no one way older adults use this technology. A 2025 University of Michigan poll found that more than half of adults 50 and older had used conversational AI and that 12 percent had used it for social connection. That tells us people are already trying it. We still have much to learn about what it means for their relationships over time.1
Someone who has trouble typing might find it easier to speak a question aloud. A person who gets flustered at a doctor’s appointment can use a chatbot to work out what they want to ask and take a short list with them. Someone grieving might use it to find the words to tell a friend that evenings are especially hard. These are choices people can make for themselves, with help if they want it. I’d start by asking what they’d like to be able to do and whether the tool helps.
People ask chatbots about Scripture or turn to them when they can’t find words for a prayer. They may also use them to think through something they want to bring to spiritual direction. In that ministry, one person meets with another to talk about prayer and pay attention to where God may be at work in their life. Over time, a director comes to know the person and takes responsibility for how they accompany them.
A chatbot can generate a prayer or suggest a question to sit with. The same system can sound quite sure of itself when it misunderstands what someone has said. Pope Leo XIV writes about the difference between simulating empathy and the wisdom that grows out of our life with other people and with God. I think of that when a response on the screen sounds especially wise or caring. I can consider what it says and still bring the question to someone who knows me.2
If someone were using AI in this way, I’d encourage them to talk with a spiritual director about what they found helpful and what left them uneasy. I’d also want them to know that a chatbot’s conversation may be stored or used by the company that provides it, depending on the service.
That matters when we’re talking about things we’d ordinarily share with only one or two people. It’s one of the reasons I stressed privacy and transparency in my paper on AI from a Dominican perspective.
When speaking with someone about this, I’d begin with a simple question. “What do you like about talking with it?” Then I’d listen. A person might be glad to have somewhere to talk about a loss they feel everyone else has moved on from. They might also tell you they’ve stopped calling a friend they used to talk with or that they feel lost when the chatbot is unavailable. That’s worth following up on. I’d ask who they can call when they have a hard evening and offer to help them reach that person if they’d like.
If a conversation raises concerns about abuse or immediate danger, follow the safeguarding or emergency procedures that apply where you live or work. In everyday situations, let the person decide what they’re ready to share. If there’s a need to change how they use a tool, involve them in that decision and make sure they know who will be there for them afterward. If the tool saves staff time, I’d ask where that time goes. Could it mean a caregiver has a few more minutes to sit with someone who rarely gets a visitor?
The thing I appreciate most about the Church’s teaching on AI is the insistence that we start with the dignity of the person.2 There’s a practical way to do that. If someone tells you the chatbot is the only place they can talk about what’s bothering them, ask if they’d like to tell you a little about it. Make time to hear the answer. And if you say you’ll call tomorrow, call tomorrow.
Sources
1. University of Michigan National Poll on Healthy Aging. “How Older Adults Use and Think About AI” (2025). https://ihpi.umich.edu/national-poll-healthy-aging/national-findings/how-older-adults-use-and-think-about-ai
2. Leo XIV. Magnifica Humanitas, especially sections 99–100 (2026). https://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/encyclicals/documents/20260515-magnifica-humanitas.html